How to start a conversation on Hinge
On Hinge, reply to one of her prompts or photos instead of sending a like with no comment. Riff on her answer with a joke or ask a specific question about it. For example, if her “two truths and a lie” includes juggling: “The lie is the juggling. If I’m wrong, I expect a live demo.”
Try it on your chatEmma, 27
- Two truths and a lie: I’ve held a baby penguin, I can juggle, I’ve never missed a flight
- Typical Sunday: farmers market, too many plants, one very ambitious recipe
- I bet you can’t: beat me at mini golf
- Photo: holding a giant pretzel at a street fair
Get replies for your exact chat
A made-up example is prefilled. Replace it with your own conversation.
5 ways to start
- Playful
Play her game
Brolivo pickThe lie is the juggling. If I’m wrong, I expect a live demo.
Why it works: Her two truths and a lie is a game, and a confident guess is the most fun way to reply.
- Chill
Specific question
Your typical Sunday sounds great. What was the last ambitious recipe, and did it survive?
Why it works: A specific question about her prompt shows you read it and gives her a story to tell.
- Bold
Take her bet
Challenge accepted. Loser buys the ice cream after mini golf?
Why it works: Taking her bet turns her prompt into a date idea that’s confident and easy to laugh off.
- Playful
Playful disagreement
“Too many plants” isn’t a real thing. What’s the count?
Why it works: Gently disagreeing with her prompt is playful and invites her to defend her jungle.
- Chill
Ask about a photo
Important question about the pretzel photo: did you finish it on your own?
Why it works: Asking about what she’s doing in the photo gives her an easy, playful opening.
Don’t send this
You’re really pretty. What are you looking for on here?
It skips her prompts and opens with a heavy question. The generic compliment adds little to answer.
How Hinge openers work
On Hinge you like or comment on one specific prompt or photo. A like with no comment is easy to scroll past, while a short, specific comment gives her a reason to match and an easy first reply. Her prompts are basically conversation starters she wrote for you.
- Games like “two truths and a lie” or “I bet you can’t”: play along.
- Lists like “typical Sunday”: pick one item and ask about it.
- Photos: ask about the place or activity, or add a specific compliment on her smile or style.
Your move
After you match
Keep the thread from your opener going for a couple of messages, then branch out. Chats that stay in text for weeks tend to fizzle, so once there’s some back-and-forth, suggest a short first date.
If she matches but doesn’t reply, one light message about a different prompt is fine. After that, let it go.
Questions
What should I comment on a Hinge prompt?
Something that plays off her answer: a guess, a playful disagreement or a specific question. “The lie is the juggling. If I’m wrong, I expect a demo” beats “haha nice” because she can actually answer it.
Is it better to comment on a photo or a prompt on Hinge?
Usually a prompt: it shows her personality and gives you more to work with. A photo can work too. Ask about the place or activity, or make a specific compliment that fits the mood.
Should I send a like without a comment on Hinge?
You can, but a short comment gives her a reason to notice you and an easy first reply. One specific line takes ten seconds and does much more than a silent like.
What if she matches but doesn’t reply?
Send one light message about a different prompt after a day or two. If that gets nothing, move on. A match isn’t a promise to chat, and chasing rarely changes that.
Similar situations
First message to a new match
Emma, 25 · Hiking, bad puns, Sunday pancakes
Brolivo pick Important question before we go any further: does the corgi get pancakes too? 🐶
First message on Tinder
Emma, 24 · Photo: halfway up a climbing wall, very proud of herself
Brolivo pick Taco order for judging: al pastor, extra lime, no regrets. How did I do?
She texted “hey” first
She: hey
Brolivo pick Hey! Glad you wrote. Okay, Lisbon: what’s the one thing I have to eat there?
Replying to her Instagram story
She: 📷 story: a beach with turquoise water, captioned “never leaving”
Brolivo pick Ok, that water color should be illegal. Where is this?
Asking her out by text
She: no idea, I’ve never been brave enough to wait 😅
Brolivo pick Then let’s be brave together. Saturday morning, the line, two croissants and an honest verdict?
Updated by the Brolivo team. The chats are made-up examples.
Add a screenshot or message. Brolivo gives you a reply with spark. Make it bolder or copy it and make your move. About Brolivo